When I first tried this I counted it as a 4-star mascara, but I’ve since deducted another 2 stars. It’s an “okay” mascara – no clumps, goes on nice, but it doesn’t have any wow factor. It certainly cannot compare to my usual mascara. There is not much to impress – it doesn’t add any curl or much length to speak of.
I just don’t care for it after a few hours because it ends up on my face so I have a smokey eye without wanting one. By the end of the day its all over my cheeks. The wand is flimsy and bends with the smallest amount of pressure. This will be one for the “use only in an emergency” pile.